Most hiring managers in accountancy and finance know the feeling.
A role opens up, the search begins, and everyone agrees it is important to find the right person. Then days turn into weeks. Diaries do not line up. Feedback takes longer than expected. A second interview becomes a third. By the time the business is ready to make a move, the strongest candidate has already accepted another offer or quietly disappeared from the process.
It is easy to assume this is simply the market being difficult. In reality, the data points to something more fixable.
What You Will Learn in This Post
Why the 10-day candidate availability window is changing how the best accountancy and finance employers approach recruitment
Where time is being lost in modern accountancy and finance hiring, and why most of it has little to do with how thoroughly you assess candidates
The cost of both extremes: slow hiring that loses good people and rushed hiring that creates bigger problems later
Practical ways to recover speed in your hiring process without lowering your standards
.png)
The global average time-to-hire has risen to 44 days, up from 31 days in 2023. In the UK, the average is around 4.9 weeks. Yet top candidates are typically available for just 10 days before accepting another offer. That means many recruitment processes are simply too slow to secure their first-choice hire.
For accountancy and finance roles, that gap matters. A good Management Accountant, Financial Controller, Finance Manager or Credit Controller will usually have more than one conversation happening at the same time. If your process is clear, timely and well-managed, you stay in the running. If it drifts, you often lose them.
The good news is that this is largely a process problem, not an assessment problem. And process problems can be fixed.
The Hidden Cost of Slow Accountancy and Finance Hiring
Slow recruitment is not just a hiring issue. It is a business performance issue, too.
Nine out of ten companies missed their hiring goals in 2025, and one in three missed by a wide margin. The most common causes were operational rather than capability-led.
Candidates notice this. A long silence after an interview, a delayed decision, or a process that feels uncertain can quickly change how someone feels about the opportunity. The source data shows a 42% drop-out rate in recruitment processes because scheduling takes too long, with a further 72% abandoning processes because of poor communication.
Offer acceptance rates have also fallen, from 74% in Q2 2023 to 51% in Q2 2025. That is a clear sign that candidates are moving more quickly and are less likely to wait around for a slow decision.
For finance teams, the impact can be felt almost immediately. Month-end reporting gets stretched. Credit control activity slips. Management accounts are delayed. Senior leaders lose visibility. Existing team members pick up additional work, and pressure builds.
The cost rarely appears neatly on a balance sheet, but it shows up in delayed reporting, missed insight, slower decision-making and tired teams.
Why Your Accountancy and Finance Hiring Is Slow, and It Is Not the Assessment
The most important point from the current hiring research is this: delays rarely come from rigorous evaluation. They come from operational friction.
In accountancy and finance recruitment, that friction often looks familiar.
A Finance Director wants to meet the candidate, but cannot find space in the diary. The hiring manager needs to review CVs, but the month-end takes priority. The first interview goes well, but feedback is not shared quickly enough. The role brief changes halfway through the process. Different stakeholders have different views on whether they need technical strength, leadership potential, systems experience or cultural fit.
The source document identifies several common causes of delay: scheduling chaos, too many interview rounds, slow hiring manager feedback, misalignment at the brief, and fragmented tools across ATS, email and spreadsheets.
None of these issues improves candidate assessment. In fact, most make assessment harder because momentum is lost and decisions become less clear.
A strong process does not mean rushing. It means everyone knows what good looks like before the search begins. It means interviews are planned properly. It means feedback is timely. It means candidates are kept warm and informed throughout.
That is why faster, better recruitment is not the opposite of thorough recruitment. The same disciplined process delivers both.
The Other Extreme: Why Cutting Corners Creates a Different Problem
Of course, speed on its own is not the answer.
Hiring quickly at the expense of rigour creates a different and often more expensive problem. A bad hire costs at least 30% of the employee’s first-year salary. Research from the Recruitment & Employment Confederation puts the UK cost of a mid-level bad hire at £132,000 or more once productivity, management time and replacement costs are included.
For accountancy and finance teams, the wrong hire can be particularly disruptive.
A weak Finance Manager can affect reporting accuracy. A poor fit at the Financial Controller level can slow down controls, compliance and decision-making. A Credit Control hire who does not suit the culture or customer base can damage relationships as well as cash collection. A senior finance appointment that does not land well can affect confidence across the whole leadership team.
The scale of the wider issue is significant. The source document notes that 74% of employers admit to having hired the wrong person for a role, and 46% of new hires fail within 18 months. It also highlights that 89% of those failures are attitudinal rather than skills-based, and that companies without a standardised interview process are five times more likely to make a bad hire.
So the answer is not to strip out the proper checks. The answer is to make those checks sharper, clearer and better managed.
Speed and quality are not a binary choice. Both extremes carry a cost. The aim is a fast process because it is disciplined, not because it has cut corners.
Where Smart Accountancy and Finance Employers Are Recovering Time Without Losing Standards
The most effective starting point is proactive pipeline management.
The source document notes that 70% of the global workforce are passive candidates. These are people who are not actively applying, but may be open to the right conversation at the right time.
In accountancy and finance, this matters because the best candidates are often already doing a good job somewhere else. They may not be refreshing job boards every day. They may not respond to a generic advert. But they may be open to a well-matched opportunity that fits their ambitions, their working style and their next career step.
Maintaining warm relationships with this group can reduce sourcing and screening from weeks to days. In some cases, the source document notes that the timeline can drop from 40 days to as few as seven.
Scheduling is another area where employers can recover time quickly. If interviews are treated as an afterthought, strong candidates lose confidence. If interview slots are protected in advance, the whole process becomes easier.
Communication also matters. Candidates do not expect every answer immediately, but they do expect clarity. A simple update after an interview, a realistic timescale, and honest feedback can make the difference between a candidate staying engaged and moving on.
Pre-employment assessments can also help when they are designed well. The source document notes that assessments can cut time-to-hire by up to 50% by sharpening the funnel before first interviews, but they need to be role-specific, time-limited and mobile-compatible to avoid creating drop-off risk.
For finance roles, this might mean a short reporting task, an Excel exercise, a scenario-based credit control question, or a structured discussion around controls, systems or stakeholder management. The key is relevance. If the exercise does not help you make a better decision, it is probably just adding friction.
Structured, competency-based interviews are also important. They are faster and more predictive than unstructured conversations because each interviewer knows what they are assessing. They reduce bias, improve consistency and make decisions easier.
Pipeline, Brand and AI: The Compounding Advantages
Skills-based hiring is now mainstream. The source document notes that 85% of UK employers already use skills-based methods, and 83% prioritise skills over traditional qualifications.
For accountancy and finance employers, this does not mean qualifications no longer matter. In many roles, they still do. But it does mean employers are thinking more carefully about what is genuinely essential and what can be developed.
For example, does the role truly need someone from the same industry, or does it need a strong Management Accountant who can adapt quickly? Does the candidate need every system listed on the job description, or do they need strong reporting skills, commercial curiosity and the confidence to learn? Does a Finance Manager need to have managed a team of exactly the same size, or do they need the right leadership behaviours and technical grounding?
Getting this right helps businesses avoid the “unicorn candidate” trap, where the brief becomes so narrow that the search slows down before it has really started.
Employer brand also plays a bigger part than many businesses realise. A strong employer brand quietly does some of the work before a candidate applies. The source document states that organisations with compelling brands hire candidates twice as fast and at 50% lower cost-per-hire, and that 75% of job seekers consider the brand before applying
In finance recruitment, brand is not just about glossy marketing. It is about how clearly you can explain the opportunity. What will the person inherit? What will they improve? Who will they work with? What does progression look like? How does the business value its finance team?
AI is also becoming part of the recruitment conversation. The source document states that 43% of organisations globally now use AI in recruiting, up from 26% in 2024. Its highest-value applications include CV screening, scheduling automation, candidate communication and predictive analytics.
The caveat is important. The same source notes that 93% of hiring managers still believe human involvement is essential, and 30% of candidates have dropped out after discovering AI-led interviews.
AI can help with speed, organisation and consistency. But in accountancy and finance recruitment, judgement, trust and relationship-building still decide the best outcomes.
Where to Start in Accountancy and Finance Hiring
The pattern from the data is clear. Businesses that hire well do not simply move faster. They run more disciplined processes. They do not skip steps. They remove friction.
They source ahead of need. They align early. They communicate clearly. They protect interview time. They measure quality of hire alongside speed, not as an afterthought.
For many accountancy and finance leaders, building that infrastructure internally takes time. It needs investment in tools, market knowledge, candidate engagement, process design and a dedicated resource.
A specialist accountancy and finance recruiter already has much of that infrastructure in place. The right partner maintains active candidate relationships, understands the local market, manages the process properly, supports structured assessment and keeps communication moving.
At Paul Card Recruitment, that has always been central to how we work. We specialise in accountancy, finance and credit management recruitment across the North East, supporting roles from Finance Assistant through to CFO, including permanent, temporary, interim and executive-level appointments.
We are not a national agency with a regional desk. We are a North East recruitment partner with deep knowledge of the local finance market, salary expectations, candidate availability and the businesses operating here
Our approach combines a rigorous process with a personal touch. We invest time upfront to understand the role, the team, the culture and the outcome the business needs. That matters because a technically capable candidate who does not fit the environment is rarely the right long-term hire.
The choice is not between speed and quality. The choice is whether to build the capability in-house or partner with a specialist who is already doing this every day in the accountancy and finance market.
In a market where the best candidates may only be available for 10 days, that partnership can make the difference between securing the right person and starting the search all over again.
Paul Card Recruitment is a specialist accountancy, finance and credit management recruitment agency based in the North East. We help ambitious businesses build stronger finance teams by combining market insight, structured recruitment and genuine long-term partnership.
For over 13 years, we have been connecting exceptional finance professionals with businesses across the region. We recruit across the full finance function, from Finance Assistants, Accounts Assistants and Credit Controllers through to Management Accountants, Financial Controllers, Finance Directors and CFOs.
If you have a live finance vacancy or you are worried your current process is moving too slowly, we would be happy to talk it through with you.
You can call us on 01740 617667 or email [email protected]